Retour au sujet

Avatar de Bhagavan Bhagavan
Si tu as le temps regarde un débat de Vegan Gains.


C'est le meilleur apologète vegan que je connaisse.

Tu parles d'études biaisées, elles ne sont pas du coté végan. Jusqu'à preuve du contraire c'est l'industrie des oeufs qui finance des cross-sectional studies sur les oeufs pour maintenir le mythe de l'oeuf sain et du bon cholestérol.

Tu dis être chercheur en médecine, si tu veux du (très) solide :



Timestamps:
8:00 Start
12:08 Macrobiotic vegan difference
14:58 One size fits all diet
19:05 Kresser’s problem with epidemiological studies
27:50 Evidence hierarchy
37:37 Food frequency questionnaires
42:53 Archer’s claims on underreported caloric intake
1:02:15 Isaac summarizes the last 20 mins
1:09:40 Epidemiological studies control for lifestyle factors
1:13:30 Relative risk and absolute risk
1:42:31 Centenarian studies
1:50:08 7th day Adventist studies
1:54:15 Epic Oxford study/Health food shoppers study/Oxford vegetarian study
2:04:44 Heidelberg vegetarian study
2:07:25 45 and up study
2:13:56 Feedback on Kahn’s performance
2:19:29 Kresser’s throwaway statements and false claims
2:23:42 Lifespan mortality rates between vegetarians and omnivores
2:26:50 Meat consumption and increased risk of cancer
2:32:36 Mechanistic speculation
2:40:55 Debate advice from Avi
2:52:00 Saturated fat, cholesterol, and the Hegsted equation
2:59:12 Kresser’s bad meta no. 3 (Harcombe)
3:09:30 Kresser’s bad meta no. 1 (Krauss)
3:18:39 Kresser’s bad meta no. 2 (Chowdhury)
3:32:25 USDA guidelines 2015 fact check
3:39:00 Grape seed moment
3:45:38 More feedback on Kahn’s performance
3:53:40 Eggs, cholesterol, and the risk of heart disease
4:03:22 Hegsted equation in detail
4:10:23 Low carb diets and diabetes
4:16:10 Collective gish galloping, and debate advice
4:28:28 Old studies tho
4:32:12 Bradford Hill criteria for epidemiological studies
4:45:27 Meta-analysis of 395 metabolic ward studies on dietary lipids and blood cholesterol
4:50:50 Old studies tho part 2
4:55:44 Loaded question “Why are the new studies showing something different to the old studies?”
5:01:55 2015 Hooper-Cochrane review on cardiovascular disease
5:04:38 Joe’s hilarious obsession with dismissing epidemiological studies cuz old tho
5:10:23 Further feedback on Kahn’s performance
5:18:31 Kahn on point about low carb diets not necessarily being high in saturated fat
5:22:02 8 Meta analysis or systematic reviews implicating saturated fat with increased risk of total/cardiovascular mortality or morbidity metrics
5:35:20 Added feedback on Kahn’s performance
5:39:18 Calling out Kresser’s strawman
5:42:40 Other feedback on Kahn’s performance
5:49:20 Kresser on point
5:51:05 Dismissing Kresser’s claim on the 7th day adventist study
5:53:00 List of Kresser’s inconsistencies so far
5:57:55 Hooper-Cochrane review was on morbidity metrics not mortality metrics
6:11:00 Kresser makes a false claim on saturated fat
6:12:27 View on industry funded studies
6:16:05 “What is wrong with what he said?”
6:19:31 Kresser being dishonest on his studies not being debunked
6:28:27 Kahn reads from the new testament
6:30:20 Kresser has not refuted Kahn’s data
6:33:43 “It happens in you!”
6:35:27 Rogan being a fair moderator and Kresser’s weak concession
6:38:49 Kresser again makes false claims on saturated fat
6:43:00 Addition to Kresser’s list of inconsistencies
6:45:49 Kahn’s mechanistic speculations
6:46:20 Intergenerational cat studies meme
6:49:00 Methionine tho
6:57:56 Relative risk again
7:05:30 Kresser’s inconsistency on the evidence hierarchy
7:08:52 Kresser yet again makes false claims on saturated fat
7:13:33 Advice on pushing for concession on the Hegsted equation
7:20:42 “What is wrong with his studies?” again
7:22:27 Kahn on point with the Hegsted and Keys equation
7:26:50 Outdated tho (old tho)
7:30:28 The importance of the equations
7:31:30 Kahn feedback on using questions in a debate
7:32:26 Hegsted equation is not a mechanism
7:38:20 Kresser on the two types of LDL cholesterol measurements
7:39:10 Major problems with Kresser’s eggs and cholesterol study
7:42:40 Concluding part 1

Je ne suis pas le plus convaincant, mais je ne suis pas convaincu sans avoir fouillé le sujet.